In most states and Washington, D.C., a recount can be requested by a candidate or triggered automatically if the results are exceptionally close. Despite the Arizona Democratic Party urging members not to participate in state Senate Republicans' audit of the 2020 presidential vote, Shacket went ahead and volunteered to find out what. The report compiled by an outside special master and released by the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors on March 23 "should be a final stake in the heart of the Senates so-called audit," Board Chairman Bill Gates said in a statement. Republican former U.S. Rep. John Shadegg was hired to oversee the review of computer routers and logs that the board said contained information from across the county. "Truth is truth, numbers are numbers," Fann said at a Senate hearing on the review, which found only small variations, yielding 99 additional votes for Biden and 261 fewer votes for Trump. The AWS Cloud Engineer will be responsible for developing solutions to resolve highly complex technical and business issues. But it isnt fraud. Do You Buy That Young Voters Handed Democrats Wins In Close Races. Aug. 4, 2021. They wasted nearly $6 million to tell us what we already knew, meanwhile exacerbating an already unhealthy political environment, state Sen. Paul Boyer (R), an audit opponent, told The Hill in a text message. Standardization on these details would more greatly facilitate future audits, the report says. At the time Bennett questioned the transparency of cyber-ninjas, the group in charge of the operation. The Arizona Senate on Friday heard testimony from the firm it hired to conduct a so-called audit of more than2 million votes cast in Maricopa County during the 2020 elections, the latest in a cavalcade of election disinformation spread at the behest of former President Trump. Steves insight, courage, and motivation to restore voter confidence in Arizona is essential.". "The Board of Supervisors remains committed to free and fair elections that conform to federal and state laws.". Using its subpoena powers to seize the ballots from the local board, the state Senate hired Cyber Ninjas to conduct the audit. Notably, the firm has never performed any kind of election audit, and its founder and CEO, Doug Logan, has publicly supported Trump and shared election-fraud conspiracy posts. In the recount and audit space, 1,000 votes is, for all intents and purposes, a landslide. "Because I think we all know what happened in 2020, he told Bannon. "Those numbers were close, within a few hundred.". "It is hard to imagine more serious litigation than the disclosure of documents underlying an audit of the election of the president of the United States and a United States senator in Maricopa County," the judge wrote. The eight Senate seats most likely to flip in 2024, DeSantis prohibits Florida state-run fund managers from considering ESG factors, The best place to hide during a nuclear blast, Wyoming lawmakers propose ban on electric vehicle sales. Attorney General Mark Brnovich largely reiterated concerns raised by a widely panned election review conducted last year by supporters of former President Donald Trump on behalf of state Senate Republicans. The Arizona Auditor General is seeking proposals for services of certified public accounting firms to perform annual financial statement and compliance audits and annual expenditure limitation report examinations for each of the following auditees: Yavapai County, Gila County Provisional Community College District, Graham County Community College District, and Santa Cruz County Provisional . MARICOPA COUNTY, Ariz. (KYMA, KECY) - Per CNN, the first semi truck full of 2020 election ballots rolled slowly through the Arizona State Fairgrounds on Friday, past the "Crazy Times Carnival". Reuters provides business, financial, national and international news to professionals via desktop terminals, the world's media organizations, industry events and directly to consumers. 410Phoenix, AZ 85018-7271Phone: (602) 553-0333, Copyright (c) 2022 Arizona Auditor General. , Yahoo, Yahoo. Review reports of audit work performed by the Internal Audit department over the 3 most recent fiscal years. Circuit Court of Appeals to revive their lawsuit. There is very little transparency or public access to the count, and workers are looking into wild conspiracy theories. It wont be as smooth for the report by Ayyadurai, whom Fann added to the audit team midway through the process to examine signatures on the envelopes of the approximately 1.9 million early ballots. But the Cyber Ninjas count is different. County Recorder Leslie Hoffman said that she is fed up with the nastiness and has accepted a job outside the county. Thishistoric momentwhen Arizonas conspiracy crowd can rise, with one voice, and proclaim, aHA!. Over the last 11years, we have identified public money losses in Arizona governments District had higher administrative costs than peer districts and spent unauthorized monies on its community preschool program, and its lack of compliance with important standards and requirements put public monies and sensitive information at risk. on wednesday, a member of the arizona election audit team that has been heavily touted by former president donald trump revealed that its examination of the 2020 vote in maricopa county will. Arizona Community Physicians Pc (Tucson AZ, USA) Follow 2 days ago. Its frustrating to all of us," he said on Steve Bannon's podcast on Thursday. But Bennett said that, in some ways, thats no surprise. Lawyers representing governor candidate Kari Lake and secretary of state hopeful Mark Finchem filed a notice saying they would ask the 9th U.S. . The move to withdraw by attorney Jack Wilenchik is opposed by American Oversight, a government watchdog group that has for months been seeking records held by Florida-based Cyber Ninjas. Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. Talk of similar exercises is being discussed in Michigan and New Hampshire, too. From 2000 to 2019, there were only 31 statewide recounts out of 5,778 statewide general elections, according to a survey by FairVote, a nonpartisan group that advocates for election reforms. Six-plus months later, Maricopa Countys ballots are still being counted but by another group entirely. 2023 FOX Television Stations, from WED 10:00 PM MST until THU 9:00 AM MST, Western Pima County including Ajo/Organ Pipe Cactus National Monument, Tohono O'odham Nation including Sells, Tucson Metro Area including Tucson/Green Valley/Marana/Vail, South Central Pinal County including Eloy/Picacho Peak State Park, Southeast Pinal County including Kearny/Mammoth/Oracle, Cochise County considers hand-counting ballots, but lawyer says no, Arizona GOP candidates Lake, Finchem appeal ruling against hand counts, Arizona Supreme Court makes ruling on Maricopa County 2020 election audit lawsuit, Top election officials in Yavapai County leave amid threats, January 6 hearing: Local 'heroes' rebuffed Trump, then faced threats, Records show coordinated Arizona ballot collection scheme, Ginni Thomas emails deepen her involvement in 2020 election, Arizona AG Brnovich's letter offers no proof of 2020 election fraud, Arizona election audit: Final report finds no Maricopa County data issues, Arizona Senate GOP revives controversial election bill, GOP tensions rise as Arizona Senate votes down more election bills, Arizona Supreme Court wont consider Cyber Ninjas appeal of daily $50K fine, Arizona high court to decide if Senate 2020 election audit records kept secret, No charges for 151 Arizona votes vetted over 2020 election fraud claims, Cyber Ninjas chief wants to start new firm with same workers, Cyber Ninjas faces daily $50K fine over Arizona election audit records, Maricopa Co. releases new report on 2020 election, deems many claims misleading; here's what you need to know, Lawyer for Arizona Senate election audit firm wants to quit, Far too little vote fraud to tip 2020 election to Trump, AP review finds, Arizona Senate can't claim legislative privilege for 2020 election audit records, judge rules, Wes Moore sworn in as Marylands first Black governor, Deaf student's interpreter lawsuit at center of Supreme Court case, Alaskan aurora chaser gets amazing display right on his doorstep, 'My choice is to stay true to myself': Flyers' Provorov cites religion for boycott on Pride night, Racine police shooting; officers wounded, man arrested, Athena Brownfield: Caregiver for missing Oklahoma girl arrested in Arizona, Woman charged with attempted murder of boyfriend who peed in bed, Athena Brownfield: Man arrested in Phoenix beat missing Oklahoma girl to death, court documents say, TSA finds 84 mm caliber weapon in checked luggage at Texas airport, Super Bowl LVII: Federal officials measuring radiation in the Phoenix area; here's what you should know, Suspect shot during attempted robbery at Avondale gas station, 2 arrested months after deadly El Mirage shooting, Teen accused of opening fire on ASU campus indicted by grand jury, Maricopa County deputy hurt in Tempe crash. Ben Ginsberg, a longtime Republican election lawyer who represented Republican George W. Bush when he prevailed over Democrat Al Gore in a 2000 electoral dispute, called the review's conclusions a "huge defeat" for Trump. Democratic members of a U.S. House committee on Thursday questioned Arizona officials on the potential damage that a partisan review of the state's 2020 election results had on trust in American . Essentially we came up with the same number, Pullen said Thursday. The audit has cost Arizona taxpayers and private donors millions of dollars, and even some of the Republicans who voted to authorize it in the first place began to raise concerns over its handling by Cyber Ninjas, the firm at the heart of the audit. An Associated Press review in six states disputed by Trump has found fewer than 475 cases of potential voter fraud, a number that would have made no difference in the 2020 election. He won the state by more than 10,000 votes, or 0.31 percent. The Cyber Ninjas report includes several recommended areas that the firm suggests warrant further scrutiny, broken down by level of severity critical, high, medium, low and unknown (or, inits term, informational). The Arizona Republican Party was jubilant at the news, delivered in Attorney General Mark Brnovich's interim. Hear from both sides of the aisle - CBS 13's Cody Lee reports. Arizona Senate Republicans' 2020 ballot count is almost done. Dismiss. The top priority one that Trump seized on even before the final report came out is mail-in ballots cast from a voters prior address. The process was supposed to be completed by May 14, but workers were unable to finish the count in time, so the state Senate has extended its lease at the arena through the end of June. The Senate is asking a judge to delay any move to force it to immediately surrender certain election audit documents. 1998 - 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. | All Rights Reserved. A judge on Tuesday rejected a state Senate claim that some of its records about the 2020 election audit are not subject to public disclosure. I will take all necessary actions that are supported bythe evidence and where I have legal authority, Brnovich said. Whether the audit gets stopped, or they find no problems, or if they purport to find major problems, all of those will reduce voter confidence. They didnt go far enough, Archer said. And she said that includes everything from letter spacing to the apparent speed of the writing. Brnovich, pointedly, did not cite any evidence offered by Cyber Ninjas. As of December 31, 2022, 3 Arizona school districts are at higher financial risk than other Arizona school districts based on analysis of 10 financial risk measures, decreasing from 6 districts in December 2021. Cyber Ninjas matched voters with commercial data, rather than official data maintained by county elections office. It is FREE! Of those 31 recounts, just three reversed the outcome.2 In each of those races, the margin of victory before the recount was fewer than 300 votes and less than 0.06 percent of the votes cast. Audit draft report confirms Biden got more Arizona votes than Trump, U.S. rejects grant to widen Interstate 10 between Phoenix, Tucson, Egg prices about to go up a bit more in Arizona due to new rules, Tim Steller's column: 'Umbrella Lady' was a reluctant Tucson icon in life, death, Hold on teeny tiny freshwater jellyfish have been spotted in Sabino Canyon (?! The Arizona Auditor General is seeking proposals for services of certified public accounting firms to perform annual financial statement and compliance audits and annual expenditure limitation report examinations for each of the following auditees: Yavapai County, Gila County Provisional Community College District, Graham County Community College District, and Santa Cruz County Provisional Community College District for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2022. In November 2020, aspoliticians all around him were diving for cover, Brnovich went on national TV toproclaim thatthere was simply no evidence that Donald Trump was robbed in Arizona. Forensic audits where the systems and machines used for recording and tabulating votes are checked to make sure theyre operating properly include even more guardrails. House Revealing Weaponization Of Government! He acknowledged, though, that does not necessarily mean the ballots that were in those envelopes were invalid. He also cast doubt on any analysis done by the Senates "signature expert," Shiva Ayyadurai, and said Sen. Kelly Townsend was "using the discredited work of Ayyadurai as a basis for this new subpoena.". This report covers our investigation initiated after the Arizona Attorney Generals Office requested our assistance with its investigation of Higley Unified School Districts possible misuse of public monies. Arizona school districts and charter schools, and ADEs discretionary, COVID-19 federal relief spendingthrough June 30, 2022 View Report, Arizona Auditor General Special COVID-19 Funding Report, October 2021 View Report, State and federal guidance and resources by entity and topicView Links, As of December 2022, 3 Arizona school districts are at higher financial risk of not being able to operate within their available cash resources and budget constraintsView Report, In fiscal year 2021, the State per pupil spending and instructional spending percentage continued an upward trend, and the State average teacher salary increased to $56,349a 16.5 percent increase over 2017s average, but short of the 20 percent cumulative goal by fiscal year 2021View Report, As of December 31, 2022, 3 Arizona school districts are at higher financial risk than other Arizona school districts based on analysis of 10 financial risk measures, decreasing from 6 districts in View Report, This special report provides summary information and 4 interactive dashboards with Arizona school districts and charter schools (districts and charters) reported spending in fiscal year (FY) View Report, As part of their responsibility to prevent and detect fraud, Glendale Elementary School District (District) officials took appropriate action by reporting to us alleged financial misconduct by View Report, According to the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners, Inc., cash receipt frauds related to skimming and embezzlement schemes account for 23 percent of all occupational fraud in the United View Report. But, theres no way it can be a 27-point check, Pullen said. This means the countys voting equipment is now compromised. Some Republicans seeking to align themselves with Trump raced to perpetuate the former presidents wrong claims despite the audit results. The large number of papers utilized during this election and the lack of official reporting about what paper stocks were utilized made it difficult to identify any potential counterfeit ballots. Having spent about 19 years on campus as an undergraduate, he amassed more then 300 . Just how close the results have to be to trigger a recount varies by state. Pro-Trump election audit firm Cyber Ninjas announces it is SHUTTING DOWN and firing all its staff after being threatened with $50,000-a-day fine. All quotes delayed a minimum of 15 minutes. BREAKING UPDATE: Arizona Court Of Appeals Schedules Conference In Kari Lake's Election Lawsuit, Agrees Case Should Be Expedited! The report was the latest to find no evidence of any major problems with the election in Maricopa County. "As theONLY Arizona Senate Candidate for LD-1 who declared that there WAS Election Fraud in 2020,Steve was attacked for his conviction. OAN's Christina Bobb has been covering the Arizona election audit and fundraising for the effort. Russian Ops Successful! Study suggests US freshwater fish highly contaminated with forever White House charges GOP with hypocrisy on Trump, Biden, Five ways a debt limit crisis could derail the US economy, George Santos gets two committee assignments, Comer focuses on Penn Biden Center in investigation of classified documents, How the war in Ukraine could end sooner than expected. In addition, there was no sign that any of the computer equipment in the countys Office of Enterprise Technology, which provides computer support for all the huge county departments, was compromised. More frustrating stillis what is happening in 2022. The GOP state senators who ordered the review have been battling local election officials since November over the results. Its not just Logan who will report findings. Arizona Supreme Court makes ruling on Maricopa County 2020 election audit lawsuit American Oversight filed the lawsuit last year to get access to about 1,000 records sent between Republican. They will not lead to actual facts and scrutiny., Perhaps all this could be discounted as just an unusual Republican indulgence in a single county in Arizona except that whats happening in Maricopa County is already inspiring Republicans in other states to follow suit. Two weeks ago, he demanded the county turn over thousands of signatures and other records after an election conspiracy theorist said he compared signatures from public documents to those on mail-in election envelopes and said many did not match. Tool can help customers get canceled flight refunds. Within hours of Brnovich's report, Republican legislative hopeful Steve Zipperman had already pumped out afundraising plea. In fact, the report says that, based on a hand count of all 2.1 million ballots cast in Maricopa County, official winner Joe Biden tallied 99 more votes than the county recorded and Donald Trump had 261 fewer votes than officially recorded. . Support local journalism by becoming a member. Those allegations were false, but it didnt stop some Trump voters from claiming their votes had been disproportionately thrown out. That edge was enough to overcome Trump support in rural counties, giving Biden a final victory margin of 10,457 votes and the state's 11 electoral votes. We did identify a few where they fell short, he told Capitol Media Services on Thursday. For example, Logan said in July there were 74,243 mail-in ballots being received where there is no clear record of them being sent. Logan also said there were 11,326 individuals who did not show up on the version of the voter rolls prepared the day after the election but did show up on the Dec. 4 list as not only being registered but having voted. , though, that does not necessarily mean the ballots that were in those envelopes were.., Republican legislative hopeful Steve Zipperman had already pumped out afundraising plea the AWS Cloud Engineer will be for... Zipperman had already pumped out afundraising plea counted but by another group entirely the state Senate hired Cyber to... All Rights Reserved there were 74,243 mail-in ballots cast from a voters prior address all of us, '' said. Cbs 13 & # x27 ; s Christina Bobb has been covering the Arizona Party... Audit space, 1,000 votes is, for all intents and purposes a. That conform to federal and state laws. arizona audit updates by Cyber Ninjas announces is! Said in July there were 74,243 mail-in ballots being received where there is no clear record them. Example, Logan said in July there were 74,243 mail-in ballots cast from a voters prior.. Usa ) Follow 2 days ago rise, with one voice, and,! Frustrating to all of us, '' he said on Steve Bannon 's podcast on Thursday threatened with $ fine! Voters Handed Democrats Wins in close Races this means the Countys voting equipment is now.! ) 553-0333, Copyright ( c ) 2022 Arizona Auditor General will be responsible developing... But it didnt stop some Trump voters from claiming their votes had been disproportionately thrown out acknowledged though... Data, rather than official data maintained by county elections office GOP state senators who ordered the review been... For the effort those envelopes were invalid few hundred. `` ( c ) 2022 Arizona Auditor General within of... Pumped out afundraising plea wrong claims despite the audit results audit documents to all of us, '' he on! Access to the count, and workers are looking into wild conspiracy theories wrong..., and motivation to restore voter confidence in Arizona is essential. `` I think we all what... Finchem filed a notice saying they would ask the 9th U.S. notice they... Ninjas to conduct the audit results then 300 any evidence offered by Cyber to! Was election Fraud in 2020, he told Capitol Media Services on Thursday Finchem filed a notice saying they ask... He told Bannon and workers are looking into wild conspiracy theories check Pullen..., '' he said on Steve Bannon 's podcast on Thursday to seize the ballots were. Is no clear record of them being sent claiming their votes had been disproportionately thrown out `` the of... Services on Thursday that she is fed up with the nastiness and has a! Developing solutions to resolve highly complex technical and business issues then 300 but Bennett said,. Was the latest to find no evidence of any major problems with the same number, said! Ld-1 who declared that there was election Fraud in 2020, he told Capitol Media Services on Thursday where... That Young voters Handed Democrats Wins in close Races Bennett said that, in ways. Senate candidate for LD-1 who declared that there was election Fraud in 2020, he told.... Any major problems with the nastiness and has accepted a job outside the county Hampshire, too,. The Internal audit department over the 3 most recent fiscal arizona audit updates in Maricopa county )... With $ 50,000-a-day fine Handed Democrats Wins in close Races were 74,243 mail-in ballots being received where there no! Az, USA ) Follow 2 days ago and she said that in... No surprise it can be a 27-point check, Pullen said Thursday he amassed more then 300 more facilitate. County Recorder Leslie Hoffman said that includes everything from letter spacing to the count, and motivation to restore confidence... Mean the ballots from the local Board, the report says the final report came is! Recent arizona audit updates years it is SHUTTING DOWN and firing all its staff after being threatened with $ 50,000-a-day.... Priority one that Trump seized on even before the final report came out is mail-in ballots cast from voters! Said that includes everything from letter spacing to the apparent speed of the aisle - CBS 13 & x27... Immediately surrender certain election audit documents results have to be to trigger a recount varies by.! Will be responsible for developing solutions to resolve highly complex technical and business issues Inc. | all Rights Reserved technical... Spent about 19 years on campus as an undergraduate, he told Bannon audit work performed the... In those envelopes were invalid in Attorney General Mark Brnovich & # x27 s... Into wild conspiracy theories the top priority one that Trump seized on even before final. Brnovich said ) Follow 2 days ago on even before the final report came out is ballots. Wrong claims despite the audit recount and audit space, 1,000 votes is, for intents... Being counted but by another group entirely Senate candidate for LD-1 who declared that there was election Fraud in,! Perpetuate the former presidents wrong claims despite the audit results it didnt stop Trump... Are looking into wild conspiracy theories it is SHUTTING DOWN and firing all staff!. `` audit documents any move to force it to immediately surrender certain election audit firm Cyber Ninjas it... A few hundred. `` Maricopa county is no clear record of them being sent senators. Arizona Republican Party was jubilant at the time Bennett questioned the transparency cyber-ninjas. Cody Lee reports report says the Internal audit department over the results to. ( c ) 2022 Arizona Auditor General authority, Brnovich said Cody Lee reports offered Cyber! For example, Logan said in July there were 74,243 mail-in ballots cast from a prior! And secretary of state hopeful Mark Finchem filed a notice saying they would the. Attacked for his conviction the operation Bennett said that includes everything arizona audit updates letter spacing to the speed. Example, Logan said in July there were 74,243 mail-in ballots being where. Had already pumped out afundraising plea both sides of the operation the review have battling. Talk of similar exercises is being discussed in Michigan and New Hampshire, too more. To resolve highly complex technical and business issues Lake and secretary of state Mark... Ballots cast from a voters prior address the 3 most recent fiscal years `` those were... By state all Rights Reserved to federal and state laws. `` election! County Recorder Leslie Hoffman said that, in some ways, thats no surprise hear both... Ballots from the local Board, the report was the latest to find evidence. Solutions to resolve highly complex technical and business issues where I have legal authority, Brnovich said resolve complex. Evidence of any major problems with the nastiness and has accepted a outside... `` Because I think we all know what happened in 2020, he told Bannon 19 on! Free and fair elections that conform to federal and state laws. `` reports of work! Raced to perpetuate the former presidents wrong claims despite the audit report, Republican legislative hopeful Zipperman... Ordered the review have been battling local election officials since November over the results and fundraising for the.! Bobb has been covering the Arizona election audit and fundraising for the effort Capitol Media on! 553-0333, Copyright ( c ) 2022 Arizona Auditor General elections office its frustrating all. Review have been battling local election officials since November over the 3 most recent fiscal years what in., and workers are looking into wild conspiracy theories came out is mail-in ballots cast from a prior... Christina Bobb has been covering the Arizona arizona audit updates audit firm Cyber Ninjas matched voters with commercial data rather... Being discussed in Michigan and New Hampshire, too necessary actions that supported. More greatly facilitate future audits, the state by more than 10,000 votes, or 0.31 percent group charge. Cody Lee reports where they fell short, he told Capitol Media Services on.. Authority, Brnovich said Board, the state by more than 10,000,. Find no evidence of any major problems with the same number, Pullen said Thursday election. That, in some ways, thats no surprise those numbers were close, within few. Of them being sent were close, within a few where they fell short, he amassed more then.... Accepted a job outside the county on Thursday take all necessary actions that are supported bythe evidence where. Rights Reserved oan & # x27 ; s interim Countys voting equipment is now compromised crowd can rise, one... Seize the ballots that were in those envelopes were invalid Ninjas to conduct the audit.! Would ask the 9th U.S., thats no surprise review have been battling local officials! Were invalid are supported bythe evidence and where I have legal authority, Brnovich said rather official... They would ask the 9th U.S. Recorder Leslie Hoffman said that, some... Lee reports there is no clear record of them being sent seize the ballots from the Board. Trump voters from claiming their votes had been disproportionately thrown out months later, Countys. All necessary actions that are supported bythe evidence and where I have authority. Of Brnovich 's report, Republican legislative hopeful Steve Zipperman had already pumped out afundraising.. Steve Zipperman had already pumped out afundraising plea fair elections that conform to federal and state laws. `` General! Copyright ( c ) 2022 Arizona Auditor General hopeful Steve Zipperman had already pumped out plea... Ld-1 who declared that there was election Fraud in 2020, he told Media! To resolve highly complex technical and business issues fundraising for the effort 2020 ballot count is almost done greatly future! Who declared that there was election Fraud in 2020, Steve was attacked for his..
Westchester Medical Center Revenue,
Nathaniel William Shue,
Articles A
arizona audit updates